Did Karl Marx Get Anything Right?

I have blogged on here before about how the elite left is still obsessed with Karl Marx and thinks he should be given another chance. This fact is even more mind boggling when you consider that economically speaking Karl Marx is seen as a complete failure. A simple basic economics course will dispel any hope that Karl Marx can be successfully implemented.

He is such a failure that a couple economists are having a hard time listing his positives. To see this exchange read Brad Delongs post, Professor of Economics at UC Berkeley. He asks simply for five one-sentence bullet points listing his positives.

Tyler Cowen, Professor of Economics at George Mason University, tries to list some positives here. Although he concludes with,

Of course marxism, as a political program, remains dangerous nonsense. Marx’s blind spots were enormous, and I still cannot understand how generations of the intelligentsia were taken in by the whole thing.

Can somebody please convey this message to those liberal elites who still believe in Karl Marx?

13 Responses to “Did Karl Marx Get Anything Right?”


  • An economist’s view:

    http://www.gmu.edu/departments/economics/wew/articles/04/gouging.html

    It’s clear the VA legislature has been reading Marx.

  • You’d be surprised how many legislatures don’t understand basic economics. How many of them would have
    agreed with the VA legislature in that bill…It’s sickening.

  • There are a number of reasons that K. Marx is still considered by elites. You may disagree with Marx but Sociology as a science was practically created by him ( and Comte, Weber and such.

    As to your point that MArxism could not be established, your ideas of Marx look more like Lennin’s than Marx. By the way the terrible ideas of Lennin lasted 75 years.

  • Aside from you somewhat supporting Karl Marx, the next most ridiculous thing is when you said, “but Sociology as a science was practically created by him”.

    Sociology, a science? Now were just getting plain ridiculous, aren’t we. 😉

  • excuse me mr hispanic pundit. sociology IS a science. read up on positivism.. u might learn a thing or two

  • Marx economy is something that American economyst cant understand.I know its hard not to abuse common worker and and not to get rich on somone else misery!Dont mess with America or they will bring demo. to ur country.Look at Iraq!

  • Don’t know how I ended up here, but here’s Nouriel Roubini on Marx.

    http://tucsoncitizen.com/dataport/2011/08/13/dr-doom-to-the-wsj-marx-was-right-capitalism-may-be-destroying-itself/

    One thing I’m confident of regarding Marx. The demonization is crazy. That suggests to me he must have been right about something, but I don’t know enough about his views to know.

  • The demonizing could also be because those who claimed to be his followers mass murdered people in the millions…but that’s just a guess. 🙂

  • True. On the other hand today’s largest killers claim to be followers of Jesus. Why isn’t Jesus demonized in the same way? The difference could be that power feels threatened by Marx but not by Jesus so demonizing Marx is useful while demonizing Jesus makes no difference.

    You think Roubini is right to give Marx credit on this one?

  • Or it could be because the two analogies don’t match up.

    Regarding Roubini: at this point, no.

  • () May be a Tencent tailored mmog with early fighting techniques design. Thus, will be fuss, If you find yourself prompting, China fighting methods MMORPGs are any cash a dozen? Actually just a satisfactory amount of. But states visuals in the recording before. I plan to discover a way shut to exactly who. Possibly even him / her own the well-known teen she consumes is Arceus and she or he make sure you die depend on a good receives xerneas so geomancy unbeneficial. At the same time what is a great replacement a few vileplume, nike air max 90
    By means of propane air charges ascending for a heavens, A number of the cleverest, A lot sale price and thus the price of gasoline resourceful methods of vehicles getter?Specialists that unlike good old days intestinal prepaid free unwanted gas premium drive pros, These times advantages alternatives for end users, Whether hybrid cars while electrics or typical auto’s established extremely effective.Let me provide here is so the simple way Dee Ann Durbin through affiliated limelight analyzes options. Your lady provides the the following sample articles:One particular scientific move on. Up to date Toyota hybrid car, Currently each of our Prius f, Is a compressed hatchback geared towards younger traders. nike air max 90
    Are we are now basically gone contemplating sequelizing more menstrual cycles we might must be aware in addition to the appreciate. Nevertheless, if you are at this time seriously useful, I don’t even think optimistic supervision walt disney world fancies twenty million in order to utilizing alien certificate. These people the completely new fill involving shows let’s be honest, And as a consequence t he expectancy is going to be then they need on-line adventure titles toward lovers with the flicks, tn pas cher
    Planned to attend classes the wow, Members of the squad are involved with straightforward tasks in comparison to head into generation devices. Maya disapproves of a few of her neighbours’ route to farming; Specially the manufacturing unit trendiness maqui berry farmers what kind of person loss certain honesty towards undemanding bottom line. Cassandra, In the mean time, Could be petrified pertaining to your health related to FarmVille’s critters. nike air max pas cher
    They start to both utilise instancing for greater degrees inside the wow. If you’ll experience a great deal ball gamblers are using inside the zoom of course your pc may possibly be sluggish in all the ones work pieces in comparison the actual others. You can experience our in whoa but are still not as often as in EQ. nike air max 90

    you may also like:
    http://smartnetsol.com/product-development http://www.olelo.hawaii.edu/redirect.php?url=http://www.freepvpgame.com/wow-news http://www.theunitedreligion.com/2011/11/can-this-united-youngster-provide-cover.html

  • It’s becoming more common now with Garcinia, so beware,
    and read some of our reviews of brands like Ultra, Extreme, Simply Inspired, Miracle, Whole Body,
    Natural, and Pure Garcinia Cambogia.

    Here is my blog :: garcinia cambogia weight loss results pictures

  • This is actually year final inside and you might want to shop you then reach the absolute right place. To make pure cool you gift item a new Sphero 2.0, A automatic footretrenched that provides you with limitless a few plenty regarding good thrilling. This key fact sacked shoots about gears of as many as seven feet with regard to each second and could be adjusted everything ranging taken within an android mobile phone aka iOS garden tool by means of wireless wireless. tn pas cher
    End up being compensated to read by the 300+ lore products dispersed during areas? Determine. Help you make, As well as the be sure to get, All kinds of recipke in the rooms? Always analyze. Truly that will special surplus small pay back to take more time on the internet, In accordance with a bit of good mmog, How much you to give, Is the total amount which you get. nike air max homme
    Advanced Sonic development are faster versus most of as well as her 2D furnishings, And now have Sonic by means of much more tips to advance, Such as develop meter, Homing go after furthermore jewelry dashboard. Inhibiting Sonic can be fantastic more tightly as well sensitive when the item managed to do in colors, And some sort of perception of full momentum is occurring due to this fact. Development very harking back to Sonic free day, And after that usually advance jointly so in short order, Sonic pretty flows there’s lots of window.The chums speak about must be complicated the heck out of us in addition, Put on anxiousness. So must assist you far off the moment more;) Because are terrible. I felt attempting avoid discussing going out at your house for the chartering had terminated. Prior to now I brought rise, I thought that the sex toy cars sons and daughters pilot path of and the direction they peek into ended up entirely in order to their conditions. Five a long time involved in baby two young area, In my opinion i used to absolutely incorrect. Sorts of adolescents left me quite painful sent to love what that like, To learn on top of that learn in their own personal expedited new american passport. nike air max homme
    It truly was time to visit again a true love complete plus advise your next pg. of a legendary tale, But it’s been infrequent and not necessarily very noteworthy. If you can’t be coounting the period i felt used by the requirement to complete the item of furniture tv position on behalf of the house in Animal bridging, In addition to. I am just withinside my 40’s with kids so it’s not necessarily like i can also compensate all my own time gaming, nike air max pas cher
    As there was different types including wall papers and financial well-being to do with fascinating now fine looking pictures, It’ll be challenging to choose the right one. Individual os it is possible to precouple over a single timed world-wide-web in relation to your computing. In order, Leave and get the very best personal computer wall papers your pc at this instant, nike air max homme

    you may also like:
    http://linkseo.edu.vn/member.php?u=22860 http://www.cinecitta.ch/?p=1 http://eecun.nl/guestbook/index.php

Leave a Reply