Long – Quote Of The Day

“The worst thing about the Living Constitution is that it will destroy the Constitution. You heard in the introduction that I was confirmed, close to 19 years ago now, by a vote of 98 to nothing. The two missing were Barry Goldwater and Jake Garnes, so make it 100. I was known at that time to be, in my political and social views, fairly conservative. But still, I was known to be a good lawyer, an honest man — somebody who could read a text and give it its fair meaning — had judicial impartiality and so forth. And so I was unanimously confirmed. Today, barely 20 years later, it is difficult to get someone confirmed to the Court of Appeals. What has happened? The American people have figured out what is going on. If we are selecting lawyers, if we are selecting people to read a text and give it the fair meaning it had when it was adopted, yes, the most important thing to do is to get a good lawyer. If on the other hand, we’re picking people to draw out of their own conscience and experience a new constitution with all sorts of new values to govern our society, then we should not look principally for good lawyers. We should look principally for people who agree with us, the majority, as to whether there ought to be this right, that right and the other right. We want to pick people that would write the new constitution that we would want.

And that is why you hear in the discourse on this subject, people talking about moderate, we want moderate judges. What is a moderate interpretation of the text? Halfway between what it really means and what you’d like it to mean? There is no such thing as a moderate interpretation of the text. Would you ask a lawyer, “Draw me a moderate contract?” The only way the word has any meaning is if you are looking for someone to write a law, to write a constitution, rather than to interpret one. The moderate judge is the one who will devise the new constitution that most people would approve of. So, for example, we had a suicide case some terms ago, and the Court refused to hold that there is a constitutional right to assisted suicide. We said, “We’re not yet ready to say that. Stay tuned, in a few years, the time may come, but we’re not yet ready.” And that was a moderate decision, because I think most people would not want — if we had gone, looked into that and created a national right to assisted suicide, that would have been an immoderate and extremist decision.

I think the very terminology suggests where we have arrived — at the point of selecting people to write a constitution, rather than people to give us the fair meaning of one that has been democratically adopted. And when that happens, when the Senate interrogates nominees to the Supreme Court, or to the lower courts — you know, “Judge so-and-so, do you think there is a right to this in the Constitution? You don’t? Well, my constituents think there ought to be, and I’m not going to appoint to the court someone who is not going to find that” — when we are in that mode, you realize, we have rendered the Constitution useless, because the Constitution will mean what the majority wants it to mean. The senators are representing the majority, and they will be selecting justices who will devise a constitution that the majority wants. And that, of course, deprives the Constitution of its principle utility. The Bill of Rights is devised to protect you and me against, who do you think? The majority. My most important function on the Supreme Court is to tell the majority to take a walk. And the notion that the justices ought to be selected because of the positions that they will take, that are favored by the majority, is a recipe for destruction of what we have had for 200 years.–Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, delivered the following remarks at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington, D.C., on March 14, 2005

10 Responses to “Long – Quote Of The Day”


  • You’re right, that was a long quote of the day. I thought we were gonna start getting original content around these parts pretty soon?

  • You referring to Stephen, I expect him to post either today, or sometime next week.

    As for me, no original posts coming anytime soon. 😉

  • Scalia is the most logical and most erudite of the beltway crowd. You may quote him daily and it won’t be too much for me!

  • Thanks TL, and I completely agree.

    Btw, we’ve missed you around here, good to see you back. 🙂

  • Heres a Scalia quote I came across today.

    “Many think it not only inevitable but entirely proper that liberty give way to security in times of national crisis — that, at the extremes of military exigency, inter arma silent leges. Whatever the general merits of the view that war silences law or modulates its voice, that view has no place in the interpretation and application of a Constitution designed precisely to confront war and, in a manner that accords with democratic principles, to accommodate it.”

    I hope Antonin does not forgetthis quote when someone sues Bus for unilaterally authorizing the wiretapping of US citizens phones in order to protect the country from our enemies.

  • Hi, yes this article is really pleasant and I have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging.

    thanks.

  • Do you mind if I quote a couple of your articles as long as I provide credit
    and sources back to your weblog? My website is in the exact same
    niche as yours and my users would definitely benefit from some of the information you provide here.
    Please let me know if this ok with you. Many thanks!

  • Magnificent beat ! I wish to apprentice even as you amend your site, how can i subscribe for a
    weblog website? The account aided me a applicable deal.
    I have been tiny bit familiar of this your broadcast provided brilliant clear
    idea

  • I was examining some of your content on this website
    and I think this internet site is rattling instructive!

    Keep posting.

  • Hi to every single one, it’s actually a fastidious for me to pay a
    quick visit this web page, it contains helpful Information.

    Feel free to visit my page: Alpha Fuel review, http://sapokryniczno.pl/,

Leave a Reply