Is UCLA A Charity?

Long time readers of my blog know that I strongly disagree with those who argue that Universities need more government funding – especially elite Universities like UCLA. I’ve blogged on this in depth before, see here.

Robert Reich, former president Bill Clintons labor secretary, makes similar arguments in the Los Angeles Times:

Is Harvard a charity?
Most donations go to institutions that serve the rich; they shouldn’t be fully tax-deductible.

By Robert B. Reich
October 1, 2007

This year’s charitable donations are expected to total more than $200 billion, a record. But a big portion of this impressive sum — especially from the wealthy, who have the most to donate — is going to culture palaces: to the operas, art museums, symphonies and theaters where the wealthy spend much of their leisure time. It’s also being donated to the universities they attended and expect their children to attend, perhaps with the added inducement of knowing that these schools often practice a kind of affirmative action for “legacies.”

I’m all in favor of supporting the arts and our universities, but let’s face it: These aren’t really charitable contributions. They’re often investments in the lifestyles the wealthy already enjoy and want their children to have too. They’re also investments in prestige — especially if they result in the family name being engraved on the new wing of an art museum or symphony hall.

It’s their business how they donate their money, of course. But not entirely. Charitable donations to just about any not-for-profit are deductible from income taxes. This year, for instance, the U.S. Treasury will be receiving about $40 billion less than it would if the tax code didn’t allow for charitable deductions. (That’s about the same amount the government now spends on Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, which is what remains of welfare.) Like all tax deductions, this gap has to be filled by other tax revenues or by spending cuts, or else it just adds to the deficit.

I see why a contribution to, say, the Salvation Army should be eligible for a charitable deduction. It helps the poor. But why, exactly, should a contribution to the already extraordinarily wealthy Guggenheim Museum or to Harvard University (which already has an endowment of more than $30 billion)?

Awhile ago, New York’s Lincoln Center had a gala supported by the charitable contributions of hedge-fund industry leaders, some of whom take home $1 billion a year. I may be missing something, but this doesn’t strike me as charity. Poor New Yorkers rarely attend concerts at Lincoln Center.

It turns out that only an estimated 10% of all charitable deductions are directed at the poor. So here’s a modest proposal. At a time when the number of needy continues to rise, when government doesn’t have the money to do what’s necessary for them and when America’s very rich are richer than ever, we should revise the tax code: Focus the charitable deduction on real charities.

If the donation goes to an institution or agency set up to help the poor, the donor gets a full deduction. If the donation goes somewhere else — to an art palace, a university, a symphony or any other nonprofit — the donor gets to deduct only half of the contribution.

Robert B. Reich, author of “Supercapitalism: The Transformation of Business, Democracy, and Everyday Life,” was secretary of Labor under President Clinton.

The full article can be found here. However, though he makes good points, there are still some reservations I have with his solution. The economist blog also mentions very important objections to his proposal, see here.

So what is my solution? I propose we take the middle ground. If your goal is a higher percentage of minorities and disadvantaged youths attending college, then why not directly subsidize them?

As I said in a previous post on this, if I were governor (and kudos to the Governator for proposing this), the way I would structure the system is in one hand increase tuition for all students by capping state subsidies, thereby decreasing the tax burden of all state citizens, and in the other hand use a fraction of that money to help low income families, whether they be middle or lower class. This has the added benefit of directly subsidizing the poor instead of through the -often very inefficient – middle man of Universities. So under my plan the poor and middle class students at these Universities would most likely wind up with even more assistance than is currently done under the current method.

If subsidies are your goal, direct subsidies are almost always the more efficient method. So if you want to subsidies poor students who can’t afford education, directly subsidies them, not some institution that primarily caters to the rich and already well connected.

Update: More here and here.

35 Responses to “Is UCLA A Charity?”

  • A lot of people who give to institutions of higher education know very well that their money is not going for scholarships or other aspects that would make education for low income students more affordable. For instance, I just donated to the UCLA Fund. My money is going to help the band travel and pay for new uniforms. I’m doing it because alumni helped fun me when I was in the band. I think later I’ll donate to the scholarship fund for the alumni association since I was a beneficiary of one of those scholarships

    Anyway, to keep this short (not that you know anything about short comments), when higher education researchers examine high tuition/high aid models they discover that the high aid doesn’t really come through. Also, a lot of low income students who are eligible for higher education don’t apply when they see the price tag because they and their families don’t know much about how financial aid works. Finally, increasing fees does hurt low income students. Just ask those who can’t get financial aid ’cause they’re undocumented.

    California made a commitment a long time ago not to charge tuition. Even now, the only people who pay tuition at a place like UCLA or UCSD are the non-resident students (out of state, international). Us resident students pay “fees”. Eh, same difference.

    Oh, one more thing. I got a lot of financial aid as an undergraduate. My fees were subsidized completely by Cal Grants and I got other federal grants, private scholarships. I also worked (I think work is good, as long as its not too much) and took some loans. Students from similar backgrounds as me are doing the same now, but they’re also taking out more loans and graduating with more debt for the same education. That sucks.

    Wow. That wasn’t short at all. Now I know how your comments get so damn long.

  • Exactly – its alot easier (and hence shorter) to make a claim than to answer one. And since I tend to be on the answering side of comments more than on the claiming side, my comments tend to be longer. Glad you feel my pain. 😉

    Btw, you have yet to rebut my claim that directly funding low income students (and undocumented immigrants, if you like) is more efficient than funding Universities in the hopes that tuition will drop. That is really the heart of my claim…but if you want to champion lower tuition rates for UC’s, of which 95%+ of the students are not low income – and a large percentage are in fact upper income – and call that a low income policy, that is your choice. But I respectfully disagree. 🙂

  • Dude, that’s so not true. UCLA has a high number of students who receive Pell Grants which typically indicates low income students. In 2004-2005 37.2% of students received the Pell Grant (Chronicle of Higher Education).

    I didn’t call anything a low income policy. Don’t put words in my mouth. I’m just offering more sides of the debate based on my knowledge of higher education, policy and funding. I didn’t rebut your claim, because based on the evidence I’ve seen, I don’t know what’s more efficient.

    I don’t advocate increased funding for the UC in the hope that tuition/fees will remain level or even decrease. In fact, UC has been simultaneously getting increasing funding from the state (not that it’s much, and waaaay less than it was in the past) and increasing the cost of attendance through fee increases. The Governor and heads of CSU and UC struck out this deal in 2004. In that deal they decided that up to 33% of the fee increases could be “returned to aid” for students who need financial assistance. In one year, they kept the RTA at 25%.

  • Orale HP,

    This is a fantastic subject to write about. I think directly subsidizing college students is far more efficient than donating to universities, who usually spend funds on faculty needs rather than student needs. Another good reason to fund college students directly is because government-based financial aid does not always work.

    In my home state of New York, dumbass Geroge Pataki cut down the amount of state aid a student can recieve. As a result I have been going to college with only federal aid for the last three years, and have had to pay for 10 percent of my tuition (via a Sallie Mae tuition payment plan, which has its own administrative fees) as well as books and transportation. I have not purchased any school books for the last three semesters, having to make friends with classmates just so I can share their textbooks or using reserve copies (if available) at my college’s library.

    What state a college student lives in dictates the terms of their eligiblity for state-based financial aid, because federal aid often does not pay enough money.

    Another flaw with government-based financial aid is also the political aspects of eligibility. I’ve been going to college since 1996 (dropped out twice, went part time a few semesters) and until 2000, only a felony conviction would bar you from receiving federal financial aid. However, George W. Bush changed all that by forcing the U.S. Dept. of Education to bar any students from federal aid if they have had ANY DRUG-RELATED CONVICTION. Bear in mind, brother, that a conviction can be anything from a summons for possession or community service and not necessarily jail time.

    This is a messed up condition, considering that many poor young people have often grew up in neighborhoods where drug use, dealing and trafficking was commonplace and many young people have often turned to the drug trade as a source of income when there are no jobs available, especially when local Deminnazis fight hard to keep big employers like Wal-Mart out of cities like New York.

    The messed up part is when young people get caught with a simple possession charge, serve their time and try to go legit by going to college and pursuing a means of income that doesn’t involve looking over their shoulder and then they find out they can’t get any federal aid to help pay for college. And if you’re poor, no federal aid means no college, which means the only thing left for them is a low-wage job in a world where a college degree increasingly determines how far employers will allow you to advance within a company, and of course selling drugs, which will eventually land you more jail time.

    Anything to keep the brown and black men down, I suppose, since the drug game is a male-dominated industry. My college is located in a predominantly African-American neighborhood, and female students outnumber male students four to one. And most of the male students are, like me, not African-American.

    My university, the City University of New York, has recognized this same sad phenomenon at their other black campuses and are trying to figure out how to get more black men in college. They set up the Black Male Initiative ( to try and attract black men. This program reflect racist perceptions to me because it suggests that black men are either too lazy to go to college, are not interested in learning or are too dumb to understand how a college degree will help them.

    I know a lot of brothers, black and Latino who would like to go to college, but lack the funds to do so and have drug-related convictions. The Black Male Intiative should focus instead in removing that stipulation from the federal financial aid eligibility rules or at least directly subsidizing black men who cannot afford college.

    BTW, I don’t give a shit how long or short your posts or comments are. Just keep on keeping it real, and you’ll be all right!


    I’ve had a dream for the last few years that I would

  • Hey, your dream description got cut off! Now I’m curious…what was the dream about?

    I agree with alot of what you say…especially the drug clause in financial aid, just stupid. As usual, thanks for chiming in brother.

  • You could possibly unquestionably visit your knowledge within the function you are submitting. The entire world desires even more enthusiastic freelancers as you who may not be frightened to say where did they believe that. Everyday adhere to your own soul.

  • Pour les:-Supplement de perte de poids le Garcinia Cambogia est absolument
    sûr de consommer par n’importe qui.

    Here is my web site garcinia cambogia extract reviews mayo
    clinic (Katherine)

  • NGvyw2 lwmydpswbnus, [url=]zilusnhjmrjt[/url], [link=]dhpmruvqpddn[/link],

  • Hello Web Admin, I noticed that your On-Page SEO is is missing a few factors, for one you do not use all three H tags in your post, also I notice that you are not using bold or italics properly in your SEO optimization. On-Page SEO means more now than ever since the new Google update: Panda. No longer are backlinks and simply pinging or sending out a RSS feed the key to getting Google PageRank or Alexa Rankings, You now NEED On-Page SEO. So what is good On-Page SEO?First your keyword must appear in the title.Then it must appear in the URL.You have to optimize your keyword and make sure that it has a nice keyword density of 3-5% in your article with relevant LSI (Latent Semantic Indexing). Then you should spread all H1,H2,H3 tags in your article.Your Keyword should appear in your first paragraph and in the last sentence of the page. You should have relevant usage of Bold and italics of your keyword.There should be one internal link to a page on your blog and you should have one image with an alt tag that has your keyword….wait there’s even more Now what if i told you there was a simple WordPress plugin that does all the On-Page SEO, and automatically for you? That’s right AUTOMATICALLY, just watch this 4minute video for more information at. Seo Plugin

  • Is UCLA A Charity? « Hispanic Pundit

  • Caring for your pores and skin can certainly make it seem healthful and provide you a healthy entire body as well. He played in 17 games for the Mariners, hitting .Mistake #4: Making Too Many RulesThere are many, many rules of golf, most of which we do not know and do not think about. They wong 52 games between them.Mistake #2: Not Preparing the EquipmentThe last thing you and your kids want to be doing on the course is fumbling around the golf bags looking for golf balls, tees, ball markers, etc.
    NFL Jerseys Cheap

  • The chart below reveals the results of a meta-analysis of 9 distinct studies
    that included a total of 706 participants.

    Also visit my webpage … garcinia cambogia results 1 month (Ladonna)

  • Livraison rapide, très bel, beau cuir

  • Garcinia cambogia is a relatively new tendency in the dietary supplement community.

    Here is my weblog :: garcinia cambogia extract gnc price

  • Given the same scenario (parental divorce), some children internalize their feelings by not talking or acting out how they feel.A better offense is not necessarily a high scoring offense and to a lesser extent a superior defense is not inexorably going to give up more points. It may be very uncomfortable to get expectant dads to don heeled shoes or boots, not to mention slightly dangerous. Gift Certificates.As human beings, our behavior, thoughts, and feelings are never dictated or controlled by others, situations, and events unless we allow this to occur.

  • It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and
    it’s time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting
    things or tips. Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article.
    I desire to read more things about it!

    Feel free to surf to my homepage; Chrinstine

  • FMiU7o uashgobyajxz, [url=]bioubkztranj[/url], [link=]kedkglsvhwib[/link],

  • They should not be too loose or too tight on the feet.-Just a moderate consumption of tranquilizers stimulants as alcohol and caffeine, but in moderate amounts these contribute to slow down the aging process.Related Articles:Practical Measures to Prevent and Treat AllergyHow to Prevent Heart and Circulatory DiseaseSome Simple Advices about Diet to Fight Rheumatism and Chronic InflammationHow to Keep Your Skin Young and HealthyHow to Get Rid of Functional Stomach and Bowel ProblemsAbout Yeast Infection and Candidiasis – Prevention and TreatmentsAbout Common Cold and Influenza and the Difference between These Two AilmentsPractical Advices to Get SlimHow to Increase Your Fat and Sugar Burning to Aid Weight LossHow to Cure Constipation and HemorrhoidsArticle Tags: aging, and, anti-aging, avoid, best, cancer, disease, fight, healthy, heart, how, lifestyle, prevent, prevention, rheumatism, stay, to, youngGreinke To Have Elbow Examined – RealGM WiretapZack Greinke has been scratched from his scheduled start due to elbow irritationand flew back to Los Angeles to be examined by the team’s physician. There was this sudden fear that came over me that I was indeed going down! I tried to shake it off but there just wasn’t time to get re-aligned.-Do not add more salt to the food than you need. History has proved that this “rural surround city” strategy in the Chinese market will often be able to receive a strange effect. All these accessories are beneficial in providing mobility and comfort to bowlers. However, the body has means to repair these ends again, with an enzyme called telomerase. Look at out any exclusive promotions on the internet these as promos as a result of highly regarded digicam retailers these kinds of as 1 Reduce Electronics and Appliances advertising codes, read through merchandise critiques, ferret out critiques of either professionals and hobbyists upon concept discussion boards.A bowling alley close to his her workplace could also be considered so that he she could easily go to the bowling alley after work.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  • However, one thing that is for certain is that he has branded himself as one of the greatest MLM Gurus on the market. The choice of underlay is huge for use when floating the floor all of which are adequate.”Soon after, Chicago’s relievers abandoned their bullpen in left field when bees swarmed a chair in their pen. Any areas left uncovered with the underlay will cause a bounce in the new floor and will be noisier. This point applies not just with wearing some sort of maternal nighttime dress, but for you to some kind of clothing.
    Cheap Jerseys Wholesale

  • I know we’re beingreally cautious. The above mention aging causes also slow down this repair process. We contain the electrical power toward repair service one of a kind photos, for instance, aged relatives images, or strengthen the distinction or obtain rid of an obvious historical past.-Do not add more salt to the food than you need. Bowlers should be able to learn many techniques from instructors that are friendly and willing to share their skills. Or the opposite side of the coin is them to possibly eat too a great deal without care to problems.Ludwick will be activated off the disabled list on Monday before the start of a three-game series in Chicago against the Cubs. In breaking a habit, it is also a perfect rule. To stretch out, yoga-exercises are ideal. These add up as the years are passing.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys China

  • I obtained all the minis with schokohrrutige we appreciate brazilian body wav they can be uncomplicated to deliver with the help of a denim jeans about or tucked with! I am ecstatic to find far more!!!

  • It is better to check the security of other ingredients, though the garcinia fruit infusion might be safe on its

    Also visit my weblog – garcinia cambogia extract diet side effects

  • The fruit infusion is also said to help with
    bowel movements, though there have been insufficient studies to support
    these facts; it can suppress the appetite as well.

    my blog garcinia cambogia costco (Jennie)

  • Normally, I hit for 2½ months(in the offseason) and then have spring training and everybody’sstarting off even.For more information about traveling, go to qualifies as an international amateur, meaning he is subject to international bonus pools. The directory of ‘oh no no no’ would be similar to things over the ‘must have’ list, but might possibly be the opposite of what you long for. These are groups of people that are all undertaking an individual precise exercise system or groups where by everyone is accomplishing one thing to obtain the most recent working 2014 Discount for Norton. Stop now and thank yourself later. His claim said a thing, yet his actions revealed a much different person than who he dreamed up. If the alley is not clean and properly maintained, bowlers will not be comfortable.

  • “Cliff Lee To Return On Monday Amid Trade Rumors – RealGM WiretapVeteran pitcher Cliff Lee says he’s ready to reclaim his spot in Philadelphia’s starting rotation after missing the past nine weeks with a strained left elbow.”Mainly, it’s been the speed of the game. The following tips have personally served me by way of my workout routines, while this final suggestion is pretty new for me, and as I’ve been carrying out it, it is in reality aided. We dont know the statistics on how many people go back to their old ways after breaking a habit, but wed bet its pretty significant.We put with each other teams that satisfy up over the internet on Facebook. A person may search the Internet to check the nearest bowling alley and may also read reviews about the bowling alley. The pitcher throws a baseball and whether by luck or by practice I manage to hit the ball. There are also three types of balls:beginner, intermediate and the advanced bowling balls. http:We can practically taste our victory and suddenly we hit a wall; old patterns of fear and self-doubt return and our dreams begin to slip through our fingers.
    Wholesale Jerseys

  • The Cubs play in one of the shinning cathedrals of American sports, Wrigley Field.”Scherzer believes that Price is positioned for a similar contract. Even if it is everything you have dreamed of, is the home located in an area that is convenient to schools, shopping, perhaps a train line to NY and the interstate and is the area positioned to hold its value? can help you with the resources to analyze the areas you are considering based on your childrens school needs and where you work. Wrong! I have heard too many buyers tell me they are O. It was all available with earlier, faster, less expensive, and less intrusive operating systems.

  • If you set up and also adhere to a good technique, you’ll end up the manager of a rewarding business very quickly. Keep in mind the details and examples described in these tips. Check a business directory to find a local agent who will know about your community.Gather a list of addresses in your target location and then send them a free information package about your yield or service. And if we don’tcome up with someone to pitch Friday, we may have to ask the big boy togo out there.The need for Motorola Atrix accessories is on the rise.Another factor that bowlers will typically consider when shopping around for the perfect style of bowling shoe is the aesthetic value of the show itself. However, wood has more advantages over steel such as better insulation, easy reparability and the need to be painted every 5 years can be disregarded. A case and a screen protector are the most inexpensive accessories that get the job done. Spates | Posted in Home and FamilyThe roof is a large and costly structure to maintain to prevent deterioration and ongoing repairs.
    Wholesale Jerseys

  • Thats enough teams to make any town happy, but the City Of Broad Shoulders has even more to offer sports fans. It s no surprise that a city as large as Chicago has five teams competing in the four premiere North American professional sports leagues. Not only will the inspection disclose flaws of the home, a good inspector will give you sound advice on maintaining your home for the years to come.Schierholtz can earn an additional $500,000 in performance bonuses, the source said.Next!MS#35.

  • In case you are making dollars online, search engine optimisation is definitely an important device.Philadelphia isn’t in the mix to sign Lester, but where he lands will help set the trade market for Cole Hamels.If you would like additional reveal you to ultimately online search engine choice, make certain any running a blog you do is performed by your own site.Yankees Expect Granderson Youkilis To Return Soon – RealGM WiretapThe Yankees could have both Curtis Granderson and Kevin Youkilis back by around mid-May, according to an ESPN.Weiner said that players have expressed interest in making the sanctions for failed drugtests more severe. Sell tickets at an inexpensive price for a high-priced item. They will aid you learn how your customers are using the site and identify weak links in the sales chain.The need for Motorola Atrix accessories is on the rise. If you consider that you are going to have to give one thing away each and every time you purchase, you might feel a lot more about what you happen to be buying!If you do not put on your shirt unfastened, it is essential to put on a belt.A single successful suggestion for affiliate marketing is to put together shell out-for each-clicks.
    Cheap China Jerseys

  • Again, a professional Realtor will do an analysis for you and you can see where a particular home is priced comparable to other homes that have sold or are pending. One of the teams owners is Chicago legend Mike Ditka, he coached the Bears to victory in Super Bowl XX.It was reported over the weekend that the Rays don’t have a timetable for Longoria to return from a partially torn hamstring. I understand that.K.
    Cheap Jerseys

  • jpg&w=375, http: a4.211 this past season, but the Yankees still badly want to re-sign him.Visual relevance is MUCH easier to sell.If you are sensation piratical, then the Alluring Swashbuckler is just the issue for you. Also included with this outfit are faucet shorts, stripy stockings, fingerless gloves and a adorable minor black prime hat adorned with a pink velvet ribbon and pink feather.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys

  • I will immediately snatch your rss feed as I can’t find your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service.
    Do you’ve any? Please allow me recognize in order that I could subscribe.

    My web site; Jim

  • . They also compete at the UIC Pavilion.Mets Mulling Options As Matt Harveys Struggles Continue RealGM WiretapMatt Harvey struggled against the Washington Nationals on Tuesday night after lobbying to make the start amid a run of troubling appearances.”The biggest advice I can give is when you come to the park, it has to all be about winning,” Scherzer said.The Fire franchise experienced immediate success winning both the MLS Cup and the U.

Leave a Reply