Open Letter To Bernie Sanders

A great post by my second favorite economist:

You want to raise the minimum wage and prevent what you allege to be “corporately backed” freer trade. Your positions are inconsistent with each other.

Presumably you believe that higher minimum wages (contrary to the prediction of basic economic reasoning) cause no, or only vanishingly few, low-skilled workers to lose their jobs. That is, you believe that employers respond to higher minimum wages in ways that do not include further economizing on the amounts of low-skilled labor they employ. Put differently, in your analysis of the minimum wage, domestic employment isn’t at all sensitive to wage rates.

Yet you oppose the Trans-Pacific Trade Agreement because you are convinced that the freer trade this agreement spawns will “allow corporations to outsource even more jobs overseas.” So when the topic at hand is international trade, you believe that domestic employment is sensitive to wage rates.

Can you explain why firms cannot or will not substitute out of higher-cost labor (say, by using labor-saving machinery) when the minimum wage rises, but are eager and able to substitute out of higher-cost labor when tariffs fall?

38 Responses to “Open Letter To Bernie Sanders”


  • At the moment the cost of mechanizing the work force, is not technologically or economically feasible.(it may be possible in the future, as greater leaps in technology lead to jobs being filled by automated programs). A raise in the minimum wage would provide a large stimulus to the immediate amount of money spent in the economy. Its effects may not be viable further in the future when such technological advancements replace and automate jobs, it should be done before that occurs. I have returned to this blog after five years of absence and I am sad to say that your thoughts have not changed despite the empirical data which has debunked the; trickle down theory, charter schools; and the vast amount of knowledge released acknowledging the growth and expansion of global warming. Good luck with your endeavors although it seems you are an ideologue rather than someone whom seeks facts, truths .

  • Perhaps one reason Sanders doesn’t think minimum wage increases cause job losses due to employers replacing workers with machines is because many studies have shown that when the minimum wage goes up we don’t see any statistically significant level of job loss. However increases in outsourcing of labor have correlated to depressed wages for the middle class, which has had a follow on effect with US economic performance. Less money in the pockets of the middle class and poor does cause reductions in demand, which negatively impact economic growth.

    Again what we get from conservatives is stories. It’s a plausible sounding story that you’ll get replaced with a machine if minimum wage goes up. But where is the real world evidence?

    My personal experience is that I bought off on the right wing stories for a long time, and I think that was understandable. Stories can be produced very quickly so you have an initial basis for a conclusion. But then it’s time to do a little more heavy lifting and look at the actual real world data. That’s what has caused a shift in my thinking. Maybe you heard of the recent story of how the IMF has conceded that so called trickle down economics doesn’t work. A rising tide does not lift all boats. There’s recent research from EPI that higher CEO pay does not correlate to improved performance for a corporation. The idea that the salaries are so high because this is what a corporation is compelled to do to compete for top talent, that’s plausible sounding and makes logical sense. I accepted that as a younger person that hadn’t looked deeper. Having looked deeper I’ve become convinced that the real world evidence repeatedly refutes conservative arguments.

    At some point you have to learn from reality, not just accept claims based on plausible sounding and logical stories that aren’t connected to the real world. For instance is there anything specific that you learned and which caused a change of opinion for you due to the 2008 economic crisis?

  • Jon,

    Who said anything about mechanization of employment? There are many ways that the minimum wage destroys jobs, replacing employees with machines is the least likely, atleast currently. Don’t know why your take and Garr’s lead to mechanization. Anyway…

    You miss the point: how to solve the contradiction? If what you say is true of the minimum wage – that labor is not that sensitive to wage changes, and the data proves this – then on what foundations do you disprove of trade agreements? And if the data does show that trade “depressed wages for the middle class”, then how was this done, without via a sensitivity to wage rates??

    I get that one wants to agree with one group of data and not the other. But the two rest on the same assumption. If not, then pray tell, what assumption could explain this seemingly contradictory data?

    It reminds me of this contradiction, of which I have yet to see explained. Oh and, check out a quick argument showing that the minimum wage does indeed reduce employment here.

  • Your quote talks about substituting higher wage labor with machines. It’s in the final paragraph of your citation.

    how was this done, without via a sensitivity to wage rates??

    Healthy capitalist economies require consumption. Increase minimum wage and you get an increase in consumption, which tends to spur demand for labor. Outsource a job and you in fact reduce local demand, which depresses wages. It’s all about demand.

    That’s why S Korea would not allow their citizens to purchase foreign goods. They wanted Koreans purchasing local products. That artificial demand imposed by the government is what drove their economy forward. Same in Japan, Germany, the US, most every wealthy country. You really need to read Ha-Joon Chang’s book.

  • Jon,

    The data on the minimum wage seem to point in the direction that minimum wages harm the poor most of all (read this for the long version of the argument on this). I think you agree that a living wage is better than the minimum wage. It’s dissapointing that something that most libertarians and many lefties agree on is shunned, while a policy that harms the people it is intended to help is pushed. If Bernie Sanders can’t push for basic income on the left then there really isn’t any hope for support for it on the left.

    Also, to the main point raised by the letter, Sanders does seem to contradict himself.

  • Maybe put it this way for Bernie Sanders. He probably doesn’t think the data actually shows that raising the minimum wage harms the poor. There is the MIT study that says it does, but there are others that say it doesn’t. Here’s an article that talks about various studies, including this MIT one, and points out that conservatives have a preference of this one and liberals have a preference for others that conclude otherwise.

    http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/12/should-we-raise-the-minimum-wage-11-questions-and-answers/282326/

    So if you take the MIT conclusions as a given then maybe Bernie has something to answer for, but presumably he doesn’t, so he’s at least being logical. You could conclude he’s wrong, but not illogical.

    Looks like he does support basic income though, see here:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/comments/34wfah/bernie_sanders_on_basic_income/

    Yeah, I think this is a great policy, something that would do more good than a minimum wage hike, and I can agree with you if you want to say that it’s not clear that minimum wage hikes help the poor. I guess I suspect they do, but that could be my bias. Basic income though, yeah, that’s I think pretty clearly good for the poor. If I could choose a minimum wage increase or basic income I’d definitely go with basic income.

    Probably the issue of getting it done is more murky. It could have broad support on both the left and right, but I don’t think it has the support of the rich, and that’s really the key. You figure Wal-Mart would hate it. You can’t lure in a worker at minimum wage if they can count on a life as good as that if they don’t work at all. Suddenly Wal-Mart has to pay a good amount. Probably more than what even minimum wage advocates are pushing for. As you’ve probably seen public support of all income groups doesn’t mean much as far as getting a policy enacted, what matters is support of the rich. Maybe there’s more support among the rich for a minimum wage hike than a basic income.

  • Increase minimum wage and you get an increase in consumption, which tends to spur demand for labor. Outsource a job and you in fact reduce local demand, which depresses wages. It’s all about demand.

    If the above assumptions are true, then one would have to conclude that technology advancements – especially those that reduce the need for workers – also has the same affect? Is this your view as well? If not, what is so special about ‘outsource a job’ vs ‘technology advancements?

  • Nineteen years ago, “Tenzin Dhongha had just learned that he would soon be sent to a monastery in India to study and fulfill his destiny to become a Tibetan spiritual leader. Tenzin became a monk ??? Gomo Tulku, as he is now known ??? and settled in Italy among a community of his followers. He spent 12 years in a monastery, and finished the equivalent of a bachelor’s degree.” “He had been proclaimed by Tibet’s spiritual and temporal leader, the Dalai Lama himself, as a tulku, a miracle being ??? the reincarnation of his grandfather, the high Tibetan Buddhist lama Goma Rimpoche.”

  • Thank you for sharing your info. I really appreciate your
    efforts and I will be waiting for your next post thanks
    once again.

  • Hello Web Admin, I noticed that your On-Page SEO is is missing a few factors, for one you do not use all three H tags in your post, also I notice that you are not using bold or italics properly in your SEO optimization. On-Page SEO means more now than ever since the new Google update: Panda. No longer are backlinks and simply pinging or sending out a RSS feed the key to getting Google PageRank or Alexa Rankings, You now NEED On-Page SEO. So what is good On-Page SEO?First your keyword must appear in the title.Then it must appear in the URL.You have to optimize your keyword and make sure that it has a nice keyword density of 3-5% in your article with relevant LSI (Latent Semantic Indexing). Then you should spread all H1,H2,H3 tags in your article.Your Keyword should appear in your first paragraph and in the last sentence of the page. You should have relevant usage of Bold and italics of your keyword.There should be one internal link to a page on your blog and you should have one image with an alt tag that has your keyword….wait there’s even more Now what if i told you there was a simple WordPress plugin that does all the On-Page SEO, and automatically for you? That’s right AUTOMATICALLY, just watch this 4minute video for more information at. Seo Plugin

  • Hi mates, how is the whole thing, and what you desire to say regarding this paragraph, in my
    view its genuinely remarkable designed for me.

    My web blog – air purifier (Lachlan)

  • Hi there, this weekend is nice designed for me, because this moment i am reading this great informative paragraph here at my house.

  • Do you have any video of that? I’d want to find out some additional information.

  • I’m really inspired with your writing abilities as smartly as with the format in your blog.
    Is that this a paid topic or did you modify it yourself?
    Either way stay up the nice quality writing, it is uncommon to look a great
    blog like this one today..

  • What’s up Dear, are you genuinely visiting this web site regularly, if so afterward you will absolutely obtain nice
    knowledge.

  • There’s also medical literature that discusses in-depth
    about it pro-digestive qualities and ability to
    repair and treat bowel movement disorders and parasites (this is where the weight loss languaging might have began).

    Look at my web-site garcinia cambogia results blog; May,

  • I wanted to thank you for this fantastic read!! I absolutely loved every bit of it.
    I have you book-marked to look at new things you post…

  • Hello, i believe that i saw you visited my weblog thus i came
    to go back the favor?.I am attempting to in finding issues to enhance my web site!I assume its adequate to make use of some of your ideas!!

  • Ahaa, its pleasant dialogue on the topic of this post at this place at this
    weblog, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting at this place.

  • Someone essentially lend a hand to make severely articles I might state.
    That is the first time I frequented your web page and up to now?

    I surprised with the research you made to make this actual post extraordinary.
    Excellent job!

  • Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
    I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the
    message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog.
    An excellent read. I will definitely be back.

  • I was reading some of your blog posts on this site and I think this web site is really informative!
    Keep posting.

  • Hi there friends, its great article concerning educationand fully defined, keep it up all the time.

  • Have you ever considered writing an ebook or guest authoring on other websites?
    I have a blog based on the same ideas you discuss and would
    love to have you share some stories/information. I
    know my audience would appreciate your work. If you
    are even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e-mail.

  • As soon as I detected this website I went on reddit to share some of the love with them.

  • I am really loving the theme/design of your web site.
    Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility issues?
    A handful of my blog visitors have complained about
    my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Chrome.
    Do you have any advice to help fix this problem?

  • Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with
    something like this. Please let me know if you run into
    anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your
    new updates.

  • I would like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put
    in penning this website. I really hope to check out the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future as well.
    In fact, your creative writing abilities has motivated me to get
    my own, personal website now 😉

  • I constantly emailed this weblog post page to all my contacts,
    as if like to read it after that my friends will too.

  • Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact used to be a leisure account
    it. Look complex to far introduced agreeable from you!
    By the way, how could we keep in touch?

  • Hi this is somewhat of off topic but I was wanting to know if
    blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually
    code with HTML. I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding
    knowledge so I wanted to get advice from someone
    with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  • Have you ever thought about writing an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs?
    I have a blog centered on the same topics you discuss and would love
    to have you share some stories/information. I know my subscribers would
    appreciate your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an email.

  • Magnificent beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend
    your site, how could i subscribe for a blog website?
    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this
    your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  • Hello colleagues, its wonderful post about teachingand fully defined, keep
    it up all the time.

  • Hello to every one, it’s genuinely a nice for me to pay a
    quick visit this website, it consists of helpful Information.

Leave a Reply